A Letter To Those Who Will Stand For What’s Right

Home / Opinion / A Letter To Those Who Will Stand For What’s Right

Cover Photograph: the Grant Township Board of Supervisors during a 2017 meeting, filmed by Public Herald for the upcoming documentary INVISIBLE HAND. © Public Herald

Letter to the Editor submitted by the Grant Township Board of Supervisors to Public Herald  |  January 13, 2018

Letter from Grant Township to: U.S. Federal Court, Pennsylvania General Energy, and Those Who Will Stand for What’s Right

Last week, federal Magistrate Judge Susan Baxter sanctioned two attorneys representing Grant Township for $52,000. Those attorneys – Thomas Linzey and Elizabeth Dunne – with the Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund (CELDF), have defended our community’s right to stop a toxic frack wastewater injection well for over three years. That well would receive 30,000 barrels of frack wastewater per month for 10 years – a toxic brew containing radioactive materials and other contaminants such as toluene and benzene, to be dumped into our Township.

Judge Baxter’s ruling is astonishing, but not surprising. Our Township has been sold out and ignored by every level of government to date. We’ve received no relief from state or federal legislators, the courts, and even our own PA Department of Environmental Protection has sued us as we’ve tried to protect our environment.

Although Pennsylvania General Energy (PGE) – the company that wants to dump the waste – and its attorneys may wish that Grant Township is being led by its nose by CELDF, the truth is, Grant Township evolved, and evolved quickly. The Township is literally fighting for the life of its citizens in this case. PGE’s proposed injection well threatens to subject every resident of Grant Township to a slow poisoning, and threatens thousands more who depend on Grant Township’s watershed for clean water.

During this fight, not one judge hearing the arguments in this case has ever asked any one of us, “why is your township subjecting itself to all this?” It’s assumed that we aren’t bright enough to possibly understand what we’re in this for, and why we have risked everything to protect our community.

We understand that more regulations won’t help us. We understand that our legislators will continue to blame our problems on inadequate, underfunded, understaffed state agencies. We understand that an injection well for frack waste is a very bad idea, not only for the people who live here, but for the natural environment.

We understand that the real problem isn’t the injection well, but the system of law that keeps trying to shut us down, and keeps telling us that we don’t have the right to protect our community from a company with a history of permit violations from dumping toxic frack waste where we live.

We understand that the system of law that we live under doesn’t recognize the right of the people who live here to stop those projects which will harm us. It doesn’t recognize that we have a democratic right to say “no”, which is why we’ve worked with CELDF to advance arguments that we have a constitutional right to govern our own community, and that companies like PGE shouldn’t have more rights to decide what happens here than we do.

We changed our system of government to save ourselves because no one else would or could. The people of the Township voted to adopt a new municipal charter which, again, bans the injection well as a violation of our basic civil rights.

What else do we have to do – light ourselves on fire?

While Judge Baxter and PGE’s lawyers, may wish that Grant Township’s government is a pawn, they are wrong. Our local government exists to keep the health, safety, and welfare of our citizens the priority. There’s no ladder-climbing, no plush benefits or pensions to offer up to anyone working for Grant Township. We are elected public servants who work with CELDF to make sure that we – those of us who live here – do what’s right for the people of Grant Township.

We continue to work with CELDF, and very proudly so. CELDF has been on the front lines fighting the oil and gas industry for many years, and continues to stand with us during our fight. It’s Grant Township’s hope that our attorneys will wear this slap as a badge of courage, just as any front line veteran would wear a scar.

This is bigger than just Grant Township, and we want others to join this fight by standing up to protect their communities. We’re not going anywhere.

~ Grant Township Board of Supervisors

  • TinaMc.

    I’m proud of everyone involved in fighting against this injection well.

  • I appreciate enormously all you all are doing and sacrificing to ensure your health and safety …. sorry, you are basically alone in this and that our governments and their agents have abandoned the People …..and thanks, to CELDF attorneys for their good works and sacrifice. May your vision and spirit spread throughout Pennsylvania, where most of our State has surrendered to the demands and presence of the Oil and Gas Invaders in our midst…

  • Loretta Weir

    I am disheartened by the direction this country is going, Rule by corporations and the fascists that defend these oligarchs. We must keep up the resistance and I wish all of you fighting with the CELDF Godspeed!

  • wow

  • Lester Wolff

    thank you for being the catalyst in the fight to save the environment from such devastation. Don’t let the big guys step all over you with their power and corrupt influence…….

  • BobSchmetzer

    Has this Judge lost her mind ? Hasn’t she followed the PA Supreme Court ? Article #1 Section 27 was defined and she took an oath of office to obey and to defend the Constitution with Fidelity . All other lower court rulings were cast out . Its time to turn her in to the PA Supreme court for discipline .

  • Jimmy Johnson

    What a bunch of FUCKING HYPOCRITES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! when the oil and gas companies came into Grant Township years and years ago, nearly everyone signed a lease! There are wells everywhere!!!!! Just ask the Wanchisns how many wells are on their property! How much “FREE” gas do they receive a year – oh, and let’s not forget the Royalties! Liberal whiners!